By Lloyd Sherman, October 31, 2019
Often when I am conducting a tour of our beautiful Village, I get questions about which industry is in HSV and the surrounding area. I tell them Little Rock is the capital and only an hour away. Hot Springs has a racetrack, gambling, there is agriculture within the state, etc. Then I finish up with our natural beauty, serene environment and emphasize all of our amenities. I cannot recall ever having done a tour where people didn’t come away with the WOW factor.
But as I thought more about what would draw people to the State besides our being the Natural State, I began digging into some economic data.
Did you know the following?
- Hot Springs Village’s contribution to the state’s economy was $371 million.
- Resident and visitor spending was $258 million.
- Federal health-care spending was $93 million.
- Median age is 68.84 compared to 37.6 in Arkansas and 37.4 nationally.
- Median household income is $54,236 compared to $41,264 in Arkansas and $53,482 nationally.
- Education levels for Villagers are notably higher than the state and national average. Ninety-six percent of Villagers 25 years and older graduated from high school, 10 points higher than the national figure and 12 points higher than Arkansas. Thirty-six percent of Villagers 25 years and older have bachelor’s degrees compared to 29 percent and 21 percent in the U.S. and Arkansas, respectively.
- Fifty-four percent of Village households received retirement income other than Social Security compared to 18 percent of both U.S. and Arkansas households.
- Seventy-eight percent of Village households received Social Security.
- The Village commitment to volunteerism was elevated to national prominence in 1992 when President George H.W. Bush awarded the Village a “1000 Points of Light” award in a White House ceremony recognizing volunteers. Hot Springs Village is the only community ever to win the honor.
The above information comes from the 2016 Hot Springs Village Social and Economic Impact. (See below)
So, my curiosity about what the industry is located in the Hot Springs Village area has led me to the conclusion that it is the retirement portion of our community. In addition to the economic impact it has on the region (and in particular Garland and Saline County), it also supports the largest employer in the area, the POA which has 500 +/- employees!
So, what is it that makes our community unique? The largest gated community in the US? Our natural beauty and serenity? Our amenities? Our commitment to volunteerism? Yes to all of these, but the most important component is the property owners (community) and now we can add that these property owners also represent the industry that crosses two counties and makes the character of Hot Springs Village unique.
By Lloyd Sherman, October 31, 2019
Frank Shears aka Bubba
10/31/2019 — 10:44 am
I read through all of the attachment from Wayne P. Miller, UofA Department of Agriculture Professor. I must say, I am rather astounded. It is an impressive write up and description of Hot Springs Village. I would be looking for property here if I wasn’t ALREADY a property owner.
But, with that said, it makes me wonder why the POA office is not flooded with new people moving here. Could it be, because almost nobody in what should be our target market has heard of us in the past ten or so years?
What in the world was wrong with our marketing department? Did we even have a one? (I learned today that the POA just hired a Marketing Manager last Friday 25 October, 2019). Was it staffed with knowledgeable marketing professionals? It appears the previous 11 years of GMs and board members either didn’t know what they were doing or were unable to figure out how to do it.
From what I have seen of the Hot Springs Village politics from 11 years ago, being on the Board was status motivated rather than help motivated. It seemed more like a High School Student Body President election than a serious business position. This is just MY OPINION, but the results sure indicate there was something seriously lacking within the POA.
Some people say that Cooper deserted us because he finished up and left the Village during the 2007 – 2009 US financial recession. Of COURSE he did! He had to trim down business expenses just like EVERY OTHER BUSINESS in the US did until the recession blew over. So what? When he saw we were having problems last year he came back. He still has a very large vested interest in the Village. He still owns a significant amount of property. He still knows more about the Village than anyone else. We should be thanking him for stepping up to help us.
The big thing I take from all this is, and I hate to keep harping on it, we need a MARKETING team that knows what they are doing.
From what I have seen of the POA operation since moving here, I believe we need to get rid of the CEO position and hire a really good General Manager responsible for overall maintenance of EVERYTHING in the Village. Each Department should have a Director responsible for managing their piece of the business as a profit center and accounting records should be kept accordingly.
The General Manager should be over each of the other Directors and measure each Department’s effectiveness.
Turn each of the Golf Courses into regular profit centers, including related restaurants, golf carts, and all other assets that go along with each course.
Maintenance for the Golf Courses, Lakes, roads & streets, hiking trails, POA administration buildings, swimming pools, parks, and all other maintenance should come under the appropriate Director who should be measured against his/her objectives for the year. Each of the objectives should contain a budget objective and should support the overall POA objectives. The overall POA objectives should be written by the General Manager and approved by the Board of Directors.
I could continue but you get the idea.
Nalley has said that we should not be marketed as a retirement community because that will exclude the new Millennials. I have news for her; we already ARE a retirement community. The average age in 2016 of the Village residents was 68.84 years of age, and an amazing 78% of Village households receive Social Security. Our largest market is people of retirement age and that is where our strongest marketing efforts need to be applied! Some other retirement communities include age restrictions but not Hot Springs Village. We welcome families who are still in the job market into the Village but the area just doesn’t provide a lot of jobs. If we want to attract younger families we need to overcome this lack of opportunity.
The POA has looked into providing high speed internet for the Village but it was deemed not possible due to the terrain. It is very expensive to trench through solid limestone rock and that is the predominant situation here. So the POA deemed it impossible to provide such a service or amenity. That happened due to a lack of knowledge if not a lack of interest. One cable vendor cannot provide the desired high speed service but a mixture of two or three ISPs (Internet Service Providers) could provide coverage for well over 90 percent of the Village by utilizing 2 or 3 different types of service such as Broadband Cable, Broadband Wireless, or Broadband Fiber optic Cable. Did the POA solicit input from Suddenlink, Verizon, AT&T or others when making this decision?
The POA needs to rework their protective covenants to make landlords responsible for their Village properties meeting all building codes, and Village protective covenants. The POA also needs the horsepower to enforce it. There are way too many landlords who tell their tenants that THEY are responsible for maintaining the rented building or condominium.
The Village is short on rental units. Houses occupied by renters make up only 9% of the total residents in the Village yet the national average of renters in the US is 35%. The reason for this may be the age demographics where most people want to “own” their home instead of renting when they retire. Even so I am sure there is a need for several more rental units in the Village. Is that what the POA is trying to do with their “Pocket Neighborhoods”?
Minn Daly
10/31/2019 — 11:57 am
Mr shears, agreed with you on everything you stated! Loyd, thank you for the stats! Everyone should now realize marketing to milenals is a joke! CMP is ridiculous, total waste of money that could have been used for needed infrastructure. Example of this is a major water main break off of Castano that affected a very large area, and contaminated that areas water supply. We. Need 3 NEW BOD members who understand reality, that is Loyd, Tucker, & Dick to start the process of healing our community. Minn Daly
Julie
10/31/2019 — 1:40 pm
One would think if HSV is so important to the economy of the state that politicians might pay some attention the current situation where we are going downhill fast due to the absolute insanity of the board and “ceo”.
Pat McCullough
10/31/2019 — 4:02 pm
If we are as superior as Lloyds report says how come we do the dumb things that we do such as having a very over paid CEO that we cannot get rid of?? How can we be this close to total failure and BK?
Lloyd Sherman
11/02/2019 — 9:39 am
Keep in mind the data addressed in this article is from 2015 and published in 2016. Back in that timeframe, we didn’t have the charged environment we have today. Not sure politicians even want to touch situations the likes of ours.
What may not have come across in my article was my intent to reflect that the Village was and is a retirement community and it is that condition that makes us unique in the State of Arkansas. Knowing this only supports that we should continue to target this market as our short-term objective, while not ignoring any other age groups.
We are a community of all age groups but the recognition of what retirement income means to both this community and the State is a key factor in deciding how and where we spend our marketing dollars.
Name withheld, POA employee
11/03/2019 — 6:16 pm
Thank you, Lloyd Sherman, for being the Voice of Reason for Hot Springs Village. You will be a great asset on the Board of Directors. I recommend that Villagers who Love Hot Springs Village to VOTE for Lloyd Sherman for the Board of Directors! Villagers can Make a Difference with their Vote.